Misc cases - 1999-2001
When Dave Sheppard retired in 2020 he kindly gave me permission to publish the contents of his website (originally named after his firm, "Dave Sheppard Associates", then called "MHAandMCA"). It is a treasure trove. I've not had time to prepare everything for publication but have put the main headings online: let me know if you would like a copy of anything listed.
R v Williams, Court of Appeal, 12th January 2001
Re O (A child), Court of Appeal, 15th January 2001
R v Cooper (Dean), Court of Appeal, 17th January 2001
R v Simmonds, Court of Appeal, 2nd February 2001
Williams v Williams, Court of Appeal, 12th February 2001
Scott (R on the application of) v Her Majesty's Coroner for Inner West London, Queen's Bench Division, 13th February 2001
R v Stone, Court of Appeal, 14th February 2001
R (on the application of Wheldon) v Rampton Hospital Authority, Administrative Court, 14th February 2001
R v Brewah (Alfred), Court of Appeal, 16th February 2001
R v Paul Lee Smith, Court of Appeal, 12th March 2001
R v Fell (Peter), Court of Appeal, 22nd March 2001
R (Mellor) v Secretary of State for the Home Department, Court of Appeal, 4th April 2001
Lizzie James v Metropolitan Police, Out of Court Settlement, 6th April 2001
Lloyd v Mayor & Burgesses of the London Borough of Barking & Dagenham, Court of Appeal, 11th April 2001
Orange v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police, Court of Appeal, 1st May 2001
R (on the application of N) v Ashworth Special Hospital Authority and the Secretary of State for Health, Administrative Court, 11th May 2001
Core (R on the application of) v Brent, Kensington & Chelsea and Westminster Mental Health NHS Trust, Administrative Court, 11th May 2001
Hession v Health Service Commission, Administrative Court, 16th May 2001
R v Colohan (Sean Peter), Court of Appeal, 17th May 2001
Court victory for hypnosis woman, BBC News, 25th May 2001
R v Greenhalgh (David), Court of Appeal, 7th June 2001
Akhbari (R on the application of) v Secretary of State for the Home Department, Administrative Court, 7th June 2001
R v Bunjo (Senad), Court of Appeal, 11th June 2001
R v Blackford (Jodie), Court of Appeal, 12th June 2001
Payne (R on the Application of) v Surrey Oakland NHS Trust, Administrative Court, 12th June 2001
R v Budgen (Rebecca), Court of Appeal, 18th June 2001
C (R on the application of) v The Secretary of State for the Home Department, Administrative Court, 19th June 2001
In re H (Children) (Contact order) (No 2), Family Division, 22nd June 2001
Bell v Todd & anr, Queen's Bench Division, 29th June 2001
R (on the application of F) v Oxfordshire Mental Healthcare NHS Trust and another, Administrative Court, 2nd July 2001
R v Pope (Michael Dean), Court of Appeal, 20th July 2001
R v Kelly (Edward), Court of Appeal, 16th July 2001
R v Cyrus (Cameron), R v Copeland (Shaun Lee), R v Reid (Sonni Lee), Blankson (Toni Danielle), West (Alan Bradley), Riches (John), Court of Appeal, 31st July 2001
R v TM, Court of Appeal, 7th August 2001
Court backs Wandsworth over failure to house man, Community Care, 29th August 2001
Moors murderer cleared to publish book by lifting of court injunction, Independent, 25th September 2001
Reed v Bronglais Hospital Pembrokeshire & Derwen NHS Trust, Administrative Court, 4th October 2001
R v M; R v Kerr; R v H, Court of Appeal, 5th October 2001
R v Martin (Eric Sylvester), Court of Appeal, 12th October 2001
Anderson and others v Scottish Ministers and another, Privy Council, 15th October 2001
Cornelius v Taranto, Court of Appeal, 17th October 2001
Wilkinson (R on the application of) v The Responsible Medical Officer Broadmoor Hospital, The Mental Health Act Commission Second Opinion Appointed Doctor, The Secretary of State for Health, Court of Appeal, 22nd October 2001
RH (R on the application of) v Ashworth Hospital Administrative Court, 30th October 2001
R v Martin (Anthony Edward), Court of Appeal, 30th October 2001
Medical evidence jury did not hear, This is London, 30th October 2001
Attorney General's Reference No 83 of 2001 (Stephen David Fidler), Court of Appeal, 31st October 2001
Sutton LBC v T and B, High Court, Family Division, 1st November 2001
R v Skermer (Stephen Mark), Court of Appeal, 19th November 2001
R v Grant (Heather), Court of Appeal, 22nd November 2001
Kenneally (R on the application of) v Snaresbrook Crown Court, Queen's Bench Division, 27th November 2001
R (on the application of the personal representatives of Christopher Beeson) and Dorset County Council, Administrative Court, 30th November 2001
R v Stevens (Theresa Mary), Court of Appeal, 11th December 2001
Cowl (R on the application of) v Plymouth City Council, Court of Appeal, 14th December 2001
Jailed sex attacker sues, Telegraph, 16th December 2001
E (R on the application of) v Ashworth Hospital Authority, Administrative Court, 19th December 2001
Male patient loses fight to dress as woman, Ananova, 19th December 2001
R v Anthony James Drew, Court of Appeal, 19th December 2001
R v Symonds (Mark Leslie), Court of Appeal, 20th December 2001
A Health Authority v X and others, Court of Appeal, 21st December 2001
R v Newman; R v Buckland, Court of Appeal, 18th January 2000
R v Paul Melbourne, Court of Appeal, 25th January 2000
R v O'Brien, R v Hall, R v Sherwood, Court of Appeal, 25th January 2000
R v Julian Ashley Cox, Court of Appeal, 26th January 2000
R v Powys County Council, ex parte Hambidge (No 2), Court of Appeal, 9th February 2000
R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Shaw, Queen's Bench Division, 10th February 2000
R v Martin Mursell, Court of Appeal, 10th February 2000
Attorney-General v Barker, Court of Appeal, 16th February 2000
R v James Kamara, Court of Appeal, 18th February 2000
Re B (Sexual Abuse: Expert's Report), Court of Appeal, 22nd February 2000
R v Michelle Louise Jones, Court of Appeal, 22nd February 2000
R v Barry Pearce, Court of Appeal, 2nd March 2000
W v Essex County Council and Another, House of Lords, 16th March 2000
Firth v Geo Ackroyd Junior Ltd, Queen's Bench, 28th March 2000
R v Antoine, House of Lords, 30th March 2000
R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Hindley, House of Lords, 30th March 2000
Heather Pottage v Stonham Housing Association, Employment Appeal Tribunal, 6th April 2000
Re E-H (Children), Court of Appeal, 12th April 2000
Trew v Chase Farm Hospital, Queen's Bench Division, 17th May 2000
R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Xuereb, Queen's Bench Division, 26th May 2000
Anderson and Others v The Scottish Ministers and Another, Inner House, 16th June 2000
R v Snaresbrook Crown Court ex parte Demaar, Administrative Court, 16th June 2000
Cornelius v Dr de Taranto, High Court, 30th June 2000
R v Governor of Frankland Prison, ex parte Russell and Another, Queen's Bench Division, 10th July 2000
A v Broadmoor Hospital Authority, Queen's Bench Division, 14th July 2000
Gogay v Hertfordshire County Council, Court of Appeal, 26th July 2000
R v Smith (Morgan James), House of Lords, 27th July 2000
R v Thompson (Joclyn Christopher William), Court of Appeal, 28th July 2000
R v Merton, Sutton & Wandsworth Health Authority, ex parte Geoffrey Perry and others, Queen's Bench Division, 31st July 2000
Kay Sheldon v East Norfolk Health Authority, Out of Court Settlement, August 2000
R v Ashworth Special Hospital Trust, ex parte Munjaz, Queen's Bench Division, 28th September 2000
R v Reynolds, Court of Appeal, Criminal Division, 9th October 2000
R v Secretary of State for Health, ex parte Lally, Queen's Bench Division, 11th October 2000
R v Belford (Moses Edward), Court of Appeal, 17th October 2000
NHS Trust v Mrs M; NHS Trust B v Mrs H, Family Division , 25th October 2000
In re K (A Child) (Secure Accommodation Order: Right to Liberty), Court of Appeal, 15th November 2000
Carton and others (R on the application of) v Coventry City Council, Administrative Court, 30th November 2000
R (on the application of W) v Feggetter and another, Queen's Bench Division - Administrative Court), 30th November 2000
X v Secretary of State for the Home Department, Court of Appeal, 7th December 2000
Zena Charley v (1) Royal Surrey County Hospital (2) Heathlands NHS Trust, Out of Court Settlement, 11th December 2000
Ashworth Hospital Authority v MGN Ltd, Court of Appeal, 18th December 2000
R v Liverpool City Magistrates Court, Ex parte Quantrell, Divisional Court, 19th January 1999
R v Secretary of State for the Home Office ex parte Gilkes, High Court, 21st January 1999
In re the Estate of B (Deceased); also cited as Bouette v Rose, Chancery Division , 22nd January 1999
Mr C M Alvares v London Borough of Hounslow, Employment Appeal Tribunal, 27th January 1999
R v Aspinall, Court of Appeal, 29th January 1999
LM v Essex County Council, Family Division, 2nd February 1999
R v Hassall, Court of Appeal, 2nd February 1999
R v Peter Dalziel, Court of Appeal, 2nd February 1999
Brooks v Home Office, Queen's Bench Division, 3rd February 1999
Dr Roland Graf v The General Medical Council, Privy Council, 10th February 1999
W (a Patient) v Secretary of State for Scotland, Inner House, 16th February 1999
Mohibur Rahman, High Court, 18th February 1999
R v Weekes, Court of Appeal, 18th February 1999
Attorney-General's Reference No.88 of 1998 (Raymond Martin Searson), Court of Appeal, 26th February 1999
Re E (Family Assistance Order), Family Division, 15th March 1999
In re J (a Minor) (Parental Responsibility), Family Division, 23rd March 1999
Attorney General's Reference (No 3 of 1998), Court of Appeal, 25th March 1999
Clark v TDG Ltd, trading as Novacold, Court of Appeal, 25th March 1999
Margaret Joyce Harris v Herbert William Harris, Court of Appeal, 22nd April 1999
June Cronin-Simpson, Court of Appeal, 26th April 1999
R v Antoine, Court of Appeal, 29th April 1999
Worrall v British Railways Board, Court of Appeal, 29th April 1999
R v Maidstone Crown Court, ex parte Harrow London Borough Council, Queen's Bench Division, 30th April 1999
R v Colin Lee Bowd, Court of Appeal, 30th April 1999
R v Criminal Cases Review Commission ex parte Maria Pearson, Queen's Bench Division, 18th May 1999
R v Kent County Council, ex parte S
N v Agrawal, Court of Appeal, 20th May 1999
Peter Oates, High Court, 21st May 1999
Giblett v P. and N. E. Murray Ltd, Court of Appeal, 21st May 1999
R v Liddle; R v Hayes, Court of Appeal, 24th May 1999
London Borough of Bromley v Special Educational Needs Tribunal and others, Court of Appeal, 26th May 1999
Woolgar v Chief Constable of the Sussex Police and another, Court of Appeal, 26th May 1999
R v Steven Peter Waller, Court of Appeal, 27th May 1999
Barrett (A.P.) v London Borough of Enfield, House of Lords, 17th June 1999
R v Salisbury Magistrates' Court, ex parte Gray, Queen's Bench Division, 28th June 1999
Palmer v Tees Health Authority and Another,Court of Appeal, 2nd July 1999
Beverley Lancaster v Birmingham City Council, Birmingham County Court, 5th July 1999
Fraser v Winchester Health Authority, Court of Appeal, 5th July 1999
R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Fielding, Queen's Bench Division, 5th July 1999
R v Peter Derek Gokhool, Court of Appeal, 5th July 1999
Jones and Another v Telford and Wrekin Council, Court of Appeal, 9th July 1999
R v Kensington and Chelsea London Borough Council, ex parte Kujtim, Court of Appeal, 9th July 1999
R v Home Office, ex parte A, Queen's Bench Division, 9th July 1999
Attorney-General's Reference (No.67 of 1995) sub nom R v Ian Albert Gabb, Court of Appeal, 9th July 1999
R v Pathfinder NHS Trust, ex parte Wey, Queen's Bench Division, 12th July 1999
P v P (Contempt of court: Mental capacity), Court of Appeal, 14th July 1999
Commissioners of Police for the Metropolis v Reeves (A.P.), House of Lords, 15th July 1999
R v North and East Devon Health Authority, ex parte Coughlan, Court of Appeal, 16th July 1999
R v Chapman, Court of Appeal, 22nd July 1999
Gower v Bromley London Borough Council, Court of Appeal, 29th July 1999
Attorney-General's Reference No.56 of 1999 (Alan John Ward), Court of Appeal, 29th July 1999
Noel Ruddle v The Secretary of State for Scotland, Lanark Sheriff Court, 2nd August 1999
R v John Edward Sylvester, Court of Appeal, 15th October 1999
R v Tameside Metropolitan Borough Council ex parte J, Queen's Bench Division, 19th October 1999
R v Sharkey, Court of Appeal, 21st October 1999
Megarry v Chief Adjudication Officer, Court of Appeal, 29th October 1999
R v Cornwall County Council, ex parte L, Queen's Bench Division, 4th November 1999
Jarvis v Hampshire County Council, Court of Appeal, 11th November 1999
R v Edgar Eugene Pearce, Court of Appeal, 12th November 1999
Dr Marta Stefan v General Medical Council, Privy Council, 22nd November 1999
Re L (Care Proceedings: Disclosure to Third Party), Family Division, 26th November 1999
R v Brian Lovell, Court of Appeal, 29th November 1999
R v Laurie Lee Turner, Court of Appeal, 30th November 1999
R v M (Child: Wilful neglect, Court of Appeal, 9th December 1999
R v Ashley King, Court of Appeal, 10th December 1999
Bouette v Rose, Court of Appeal, 17th December 1999
Broadmoor Hospital Authority and Dr Vermeulen v Andrew Ross Robinson, Court of Appeal, 20th December 1999
Andrew Watkiss, out of court settlement, December 1999
DSA archive