View source for Mental Health Tribunal archive

This page mainly contains out of date information. For the current page, see [[Mental Health Tribunal]].

==May 2017 office closure==
The following is the text of an email dated 18/5/17 in relation to an office closure:

<blockquote>Dear All 

Please be aware that due to a burst water pipe the Leicester office is closed.
 
We do not have access to the building and have staff travelling to other locations within the City and County.
 
We have not been able to divert the telephones so are unable to take calls.

Urgent work will take priority.
 
All emails will be monitored but there may be some delays in providing a response.
 
At this point in time I have no idea when the office will reopen.
 
I will provide further updates as they become available
 
Thank you for your continued patience and support
 
Karen Early
 
Operations Manager

Her Majesty's Courts and Tribunals Service</blockquote>

The following is the text of a subsequent bulletin ([[Media:2017-05-22 MHT Bulletin.pdf|Karen Early, 'Mental Health Tribunal Bulletin' (HMCTS, 22/5/17)]])

<blockquote>
'''An important message regarding the administration office:'''

Further to last week’s message, I confirm that the Leicester office remains severely affected by a burst water pipe with some floors remaining closed.

Staff have been relocated to alternative floors within the building and urgent work will continue to take priority whilst we recover from the disruption. All inboxes will be monitored but there still may be some delays in providing a response.

We are now able to take calls on our usual number  - 0300 123 2201 – but would ask that this is for urgent matters only. 

It is likely that this situation will remain for several weeks.

I would like to thank you for your continued patience and support during this difficult time. 

Karen Early
Operational Manager
</blockquote>

==External links==
On 1/4/11 the Tribunals Service and Her Majesty's Courts Service merged to form Her Majesty's Courts and Tribunals Service. The 'mhrt.org.uk' website is no longer operational, and the content has been scattered across the MOJ website.

===Annual Report===
*[[:File:SPT-annual-report-2012.pdf|Senior President of Tribunals, 'Senior President of Tribunals' Annual Report' (February 2012)]]. This report contains the following in relation to the mental health jurisdiction: (1) A periodic digest of common errors, arising in 'review' decisions (First-tier appeals on points of law), is issued so that members can 'learn from the experience of colleagues who are faced with difficult legal questions': this digest is available to legal, medical and lay members, but surprisingly not to patients, their representatives or the public. (2) There was a 3% increase in receipt of cases from 2009-10 to 2010-11, mostly due to CTOs, changes in status, and increased use of s2. (3) The 'continuing improvement' and 'excellent progress' by the secretariat, and the duty judge scheme, has led to improved case management and reduced the adjournment rate within two years from 20% to 7%. (4) The [[AH v West London MH NHS Trust (2011) UKUT 74 (AAC)|AH]] case on publicity and the [[SSJ v RB (2011) EWCA Civ 1608|RB]] case on discharge conditions are noted as interesting cases.  (5) Use of secure email will be encouraged. (6) Twelve salaried tribunal judges were appointed to the Restricted Patients Panel in 2011.

===Contact details===
*[[Media:HMCTS Contact Details for Leicester Secretariat dated 2Feb14 emailed 29Dec14.pdf|HMCTS, 'Contact Details for Leicester Secretariat' (dated 2/2/14, emailed 29/12/14)]]
*An email address not in the above document: tsmhrelist@hmcts.gsi.gov.uk (for all enquiries regarding relisting a case).
*A circular email from the Tribunal secretariat dated 2/12/14 contained the following information: (1) from 1/1/15 three reports-related email addresses (northreportsteam@hmcts.gsi.gov.uk, southreportsteam@hmcts.gsi.gov.uk and reportsenquiries@hmcts.gsi.gov.uk) will cease to function; (2) all reports and  related enquiries (such as extension, directions and order requests) should instead be sent to mhtreports@hmcts.gsi.gov.uk
*The email for complaints is officialcorrespondence@hmcts.gsi.gov.uk

===Mental Health Tribunal website - transition to GOV.UK===
*A circular email from the Tribunal secretariat dated 29/12/14 contained the following information: (1) The MHT information and guidance for patients has moved to [https://www.gov.uk/mental-health-tribunal the GOV.UK website] and the old MoJ pages will now redirect there. (2) Forms and leaflets are still available on [http://hmctsformfinder.justice.gov.uk/HMCTS/GetForms.do?court_forms_title=&court_forms_category=Mental+Health+Tribunal the MoJ website]. (3) Up-to-date contact sheet: [[Media:HMCTS Contact Details for Leicester Secretariat dated 2Feb14 emailed 29Dec14.pdf|HMCTS, 'Contact Details for Leicester Secretariat' (dated 2/2/14, emailed 29/12/14)]]. (4) If necessary, call the Tribunal's Customer Support Team on 0300 123 2201 for assistance.

===Tribunal member and stakeholder email bulletin===
*{{pagesummary|Mental Health Tribunal, 'Stakeholder bulletin Mental Health Tribunal administration Autumn 2017' (November 2017)}}

*[[Media:TSMH Bulletin Dec08.doc|Tribunals Service, 'Tribunal Member and Stakeholder Bulletin' (Dec 08)]]. Contents: (1) IMPORTANT – Operation of Section 77(2) MHA 1983; (2) Information on the HESC Chamber; (3) Tribunals, Courts & Enforcement Act 2007 Implementation; (4) MARTHA Database; (5) TS Clerk Project; (6) Section 67 applications; (7) TS Mental Health Tribunal Hearing Room Audit

*[[Media:TSMH Bulletin - March 20101.doc|Tribunals Service, 'Stakeholder Bulletin' (March 2010)]]. Contents: (1) Principal Judge; (2) Requests for Referral; (3) Interpreter Requests and Payments; (4) Process Update; (5) Secure Email; (6) Submitting Applications; (7) Issuing the Tribunals’ Written Decision; (8)Nearest Relatives; (9) Communication

*[[Media:TSMH Bulletin July 2011.doc|HMCTS, 'First-tier Tribunal Mental Health Stakeholder Bulletin July 2011' (29/7/11)]]. The following are the headings: (1) Contacting the Tribunal; (2) Use of Secure Email; (3) Applications; (4) Forms used in the Applications Process; (5) Case Management Requests (form CMR1); (5) Secretary of State Supplementary Statements; (6) Reports Processing Team; (7) Decisions; (8) Feedback.

*[[Media:MHT Stakeholder Bulletin April 2012.pdf|HMCTS, 'Mental Health Tribunal Stakeholder Bulletin April 2012' (17/4/12)]]. The following are the headings: Contacting the Tribunal; Reports Processing Team; Section 2 Cases; Scanned Reports; Password protection; Notification to the Tribunal of Patient Withdrawals and RC Discharges; HQ2 Questionnaire; FTT Mental Health Policy update; Clerking; Facilities for the Hearing impaired; Olympics and Paralympics 2012 and the potential impact; Relist Team; Customer Survey; Feedback. In relation to the new forms: '''Form CNL2''' ('Case Notification Letter 2'), which from May 2012 will be sent to the representative with the RC's report, demands that the representative complete '''Form HQ2''' ('Hearing Questionnaire 2'). HQ2 asks the following questions: (1) What is the Patient seeking from the tribunal, and what are the principal areas of dispute? (2) Do you intend to call an independent expert? If so, please give details. (3) What is your hearing time estimate? (4) Would this case benefit from pre-hearing review by a tribunal judge? If so, please say why (e.g. change of status under the Act, or recent hospital transfer). (5) Are there any other matters that you feel that the panel should know in order to dispose of this matter justly, fairly and without delay? (6) Does the patient need an interpreter? If so, please give details of language and dialect.

*[[Media:MHT stakeholder communication April 2013.pdf|Neil Skelton, 'Note to All Mental Health Tribunal Stakeholders: Mental Health Tribunal: process changes' (HMCTS, 15/4/13)]]. In relation to applications or referrals submitted on or after 13/5/13, MHT cases will no longer be listed by negotiation in England. There is no change for section 2 cases. When a case is registered by the tribunal secretariat, new form HQ1 will be sent to parties, who will have 14 days (in practice, usually via the representative and MHA Administrator) to provide availability during the following listing windows: (a) for unrestricted cases, 5-8 weeks from the the secretariat's receipt of the application or referral; (b) for restricted cases, 12-14 weeks. The secretariat aims to select a date and notify the parties within 21 days of receipt of the application or referral. See also: [[Media:MHT changes FAQ April 2013.pdf|HMCTS, ' Mental Health Tribunal: Process Changes: Frequently asked Questions' (15/4/13)]]; [[Media:Form HQ1 April 2013.pdf|Form HQ1 (April 2013 version)]].

===Messages from Deputy Chamber President===
*[[:File:Deputy Chamber President message Oct 2009.pdf|Message from Deputy Chamber President, October 2009]]

*[[:File:Deputy Chamber President Christmas message 2009.pdf|Christmas Message from Deputy Chamber President, December 2009]]

*[[Media:Deputy Chamber President letter Feb 2010.pdf|Message from Deputy Chamber President, February 2010]]. This message states that the 2010 priorities were 'Adjournments, Bookings and Case management'

*[[Media:MHT listing letter 2 July 2013.pdf|Mark Hinchliffe, John Wright and Karen Early, 'New Arrangements for Listing Mental Health Cases' (letter, 2/7/13)]]

*[[:Media:MHT Round Robin re Changes 6-4-12.pdf|Mark Hinchliffe, 'Important Notice' (29/3/12)]]. This document describes the changes made by the [[Tribunal Procedure (Amendment) Rules 2012]] on 6/4/12. In relation to the tribunal's requirement, in CTO reference cases, for evidence from the RC about the patient's capacity to decide not to attend or be represented, it states: 'We do not see that this should present a difficulty or a conflict of interest. The Responsible Clinician, as an expert witness, has no "interest" one way or the other and, in any event, has a responsibility to assess capacity in many situations...'

*[[:Media:MHT Christmas Card 2015.pdf|Mark Hinchliffe, 'Seasons Greetings' (17/12/15)]]. This emailed Christmas card incorporates the following exhortation: "It is a legal requirement that all reports must fully comply with the [[Practice Direction: First-tier Tribunal Health Education and Social Care Chamber: Statements and Reports in Mental Health Cases (28/10/13)|Senior President’s Practice Direction: Statements and Reports in Mental Health Cases]] ... There is a separate list for each type of case, and each professional discipline. Professionals should print off and laminate or keep safely those lists that relate to their discipline and keep them in their office so that, in future, all reports are submitted on time, and comply with the law. Under rule [[Tribunal rule 15|15]](2)(b) the tribunal can <u>'''exclude''' any report that does not comply with the Senior President’s Practice Direction</u>." (original emphasis)

===Information sheets===
[These are probably not the current versions: need to check.]

*[[:File:InformationforNonRestrictedPatients.pdf|Tribunals Service, 'Information for NonRestricted Patients detained under the Mental Health Act 1983 (as amended by the Mental Health Act 2007)' (3/8/11)]]. This contains errors (in italics):
:*''"What sort of decisions can the Tribunal make?" - "...can recommend a transfer to another hospital, if that would be beneficial"'' -- This can only be "with a view to facilitating [the patient's] discharge on a future date" (rather than "if that would be beneficial").
:*''"When can I apply?" - "But remember you can only have one hearing of an application during each period of detention"'' -- You can only make one application during each period but this could lead to more than one hearing during one period of detention.
:*''"What happens if you change your mind about having a Tribunal?" - "... you have the right to one Tribunal hearing during each period you are detained on section"'' -- You are entitled to one application (rather than one hearing) during each period.

*[[:File:InformationforRestrictedPatients.pdf|Tribunals Service, 'Information for Restricted Patients detained under the Mental Health Act 1983 (as amended by the Mental Health Act 2007)' (3/8/11)]]. This contains errors (in italics):
:*''"Further notes"'' -- a restricted patient also includes other patients - [[s45A]]
:*''"A tribunal cannot discharge you subject to a restriction order (a transferred prisoner) but can notify the Secretary of State  that you would be entitled to an absolute or conditional discharge if you were on a hospital order made by a court with restrictions on discharge."'' -- This only applies to patients subject to a restriction direction.
:*''"When can you apply?"'' -- A patient subject to [[s47/49]] can apply during the first six months of detention in addition to the periods mentioned in the leaflet.

*[[:File:Nearest Relative 2009 leaflet.pdf|Tribunals Service, 'Information for Nearest Relatives' (2009)]]. The leaflet talks about the patient as being the nearest relative's nearest relative - this is not always the case. For example, if your sister is detained you might be her nearest relative; however, if you are married (and not separated etc) your sister will not be your nearest relative.

*[[:File:InfoForVictimsNov09.pdf|Tribunals Service, 'Information for Victims' (November 2009)]]. This document explains the [[DVCVA 2004]].

*[[:File:MHT guidance note on applications and referrals Dec 2010.pdf|Mental Health Tribunal, 'Guidance Notes for Applications and Referrals' (December 2010)]]

===CJSM===
*[http://www.lawsociety.org.uk/newsandevents/news/view=newsarticle.law?NEWSID=434749 Law Society, 'Mental Health Tribunals Service: secure email' (24/2/11)] - The Law Society have published a statement encouraging solicitors to use the CJSM secure email system. The text is as follows: 'Users of the Mental Health Tribunals Service will often be required to transmit sensitive data by email in their communications with the tribunal. The inherent insecurity of 'non-secure' email is not ideally suitable for such communications. We would encourage eligible practitioners to sign up to the Ministry of Justice's secure email service, which supports free and secure communication with Mental Health Tribunals. Further information about the service is available at www.cjsm.gov.uk, including interactive training and a help desk which can be contacted on 0870 010 8535.'

*[http://www.legalservices.gov.uk/civil/cls_news_12517.asp?page=1 Legal Services Commission, 'Tribunals Service asks mental health providers to use secure email service' (2/3/11)]

*[[Media:MHT cjsm letter Jan 2011.pdf|Jonathan Gammon, 'Criminal Justice Secure Email (CJSM)' (letter to solicitors, 31/1/11)]]. This letter provides details of the CJSM system and encourages solicitors to sign up for a free account.

===Salaried Tribunal judges to chair restricted hearings===
*[http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201011/cmhansrd/cm100726/wmstext/100726m0001.htm Hansard HC Deb 26 July 2010 col 51WS]. The Secretary of State has agreed to the proposal of salaried Mental Health Judges with suitable experience being selected to chair Restricted Patients Panel cases. It was decided not to do an initial trial run first because the salaried judges will only be selected to take on the work if the President considers them capable, but the President will monitor the ticketed judges and arrange any additional training that he may deem necessary. Written Ministerial Statements were tabled on 26/7/10:

:''''Judicial Appointments'''

:''''The Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice (Mr Kenneth Clarke):''' I am today announcing my agreement that salaried mental health judges with suitable experience can be selected to chair Restricted Patients Panel cases in the mental health jurisdiction.

:'These cases involve patients who are detained in hospital by virtue of a restriction order imposed by the Crown Court or by virtue of being transferred from prison by direction of the Secretary of State. The convention, since the implementation of the Mental Health Act 1983, has been that the tribunal judge chairing the panel will always be a circuit judge, a retired circuit judge or a recorder QC. However, the convention came about at a time when there were no full-time judges in the mental health review tribunal and was designed to provide assurance when this power was first transferred from the Secretary of State to the tribunal that an experienced member of the judiciary would be involved in decisions on whether to direct the discharge of a patient.

:'There are now full-time salaried judges within the jurisdiction with the necessary experience. Circuit judges and recorder QCs will continue to deal with the majority of cases but authorising some of the salaried mental health judges will increase the pool of available chairs to hear the cases.'

===Other===
*[[:File:Tribunals Service Business Plan 2010-11.pdf|Tribunals Service, 'Business Plan for 2010-11' (March 2010)]]. The MHT's "Primary Performance Indicators" (targets) were as follows: the percentage of Section 2 cases listed for first hearing within 7 days of receipt (statutory target) 100%; the percentage of non-restricted cases disposed of within 9 weeks of receipt 75%; the percentage of Restricted Patient cases disposed of within 17 weeks of receipt 75%.