September 2017 update
Website
- Magic Book. The Magic Book is a database of contact details. It is a new addition to MHLO - but it can be expanded and be a success if everybody joins in, including you. To create/edit contacts, there is no need to log in and the process is very quick and simple. See Magic Book
- Mental Health Law Online CPD scheme: 12 points for £60. Obtain 12 CPD points online by answering monthly questionnaires. The scheme is an ideal way to obtain your necessary hours, or to evidence your continued competence. It also helps to support the continued development of this website, and your subscriptions (and re-subscriptions) are appreciated. For full details and to subscribe, see CPD scheme.
- Cases. On 30/9/17 Mental Health Law Online contained 1858 categorised cases
- Chronology. See September 2017 chronology for this month's changes to the website in date order.
Case law
- After-care case. R (CXF) v Central Bedfordshire Council [2017] EWHC 2311 (Admin) — "The central question raised in these proceedings is whether either or both of the Defendants has a duty under s117 of the MHA to cover the costs of the Claimant's mother's visits, on the ground that they constitute "after-care services" within the meaning of that provision. ... The specific issues that arise are as follows: (a) Whether the duty to provide after-care services under s117 is triggered when the Claimant is granted leave of absence from the Hospital under s17 of the MHA for an escorted bus trip. This issue turns on the question whether, when granted such leave of absence, the Claimant satisfies the two pre-conditions set out in s. 117(1), namely, (i) that he has "ceased to be detained" under s3 of the MHA, and (ii) that he has "left hospital"; (b) If so, whether the after-care services which are to be provided pursuant to s117(6) of the MHA may as a matter of principle include funding to cover the Claimant's mother's transport costs; (c) If so, whether on the facts of this case there is a duty to provide the funding sought as an after-care service under s117; (d) If so, whether the duty to provide the services falls on the First and Second Defendants jointly, or in fact falls on the First Defendant jointly with Bedfordshire Clinical Commissioning Group, which was originally joined as a Defendant to these proceedings, but against which proceedings were discontinued in March 2017."
- Upper Tribunal case. JMcG v Devon Partnership NHS Trust [2017] UKUT 348 (AAC) — The Upper Tribunal stated (probably wrongly) that the date of a deferred discharge cannot exceed the date of the order authorising detention. This was only obiter and seems to have been based on the false premise that a deferred discharge beyond the date on which the authority for the patient’s detention expires would have the effect of extending the period of detention.
- Deportation following hospital order. SSHD v KE (Nigeria) [2017] EWCA Civ 1382 — "This is an appeal [which] gives rise to the narrow, but important, issue as to whether a non-British citizen who is convicted and sentenced to a hospital order with restrictions under sections 37 and 41 of the Mental Health Act 1983 is 'a foreign criminal who has been sentenced to a period of imprisonment of at least four years' for the purposes of section 117C(6) of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002, so that the public interest requires his deportation unless there are very compelling circumstances that mean that it would be a disproportionate interference with his rights under article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights to deport him."
Other
- Aasya Mughal and Steven Richards, 'Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards Case Law Summary 2015-17' (September 2017 edition, 28/9/17). details. See Newsletters#Edge Training
- IJMHCL third edition. [2017] IJMHCL pagesM 1-83. The articles in this edition are: (1) Editorial (Darius Whelan, Emma Cave); (2) Severe and Enduring Anorexia Nervosa in the Court of Protection in England and Wales (Emma Cave, Jacinta OA Tan); (3) Analysing the Definition of Disability in the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities: is it really based on a 'Social Model' approach? (Katerina Kazou); (4) Negotiating Relationality: Mental Capacity as Narrative Congruence (David Gibson); (5) Some Continental European Perspectives on Safeguards in the Case of Deprivation of Liberty in Health and Social Care Settings (Walter Boente). See International Journal of Mental Health and Capacity Law
- IJMHCL second edition. [2016] IJMHCL pagesNot on Bailii! 71-143. In the archives, the first and second editions are both called "No 22 (2016)". The articles in this edition are: (1) Editorial (Daniel W. Liang Wang, Alex Ruck Keene, Ruth Fletcher, Catherine Penny, Richard Ashcroft); (2) Disability, Deprivation of Liberty and Human Rights Norms: Reconciling European and International Approaches (Eilionóir Flynn); (3) DoLS or Quality Care? (Gordon Rayment Ashton); (4) Capacity Assessment and Information Provision for Voluntary Psychiatric Patients: a service evaluation in a UK NHS Trust (Benjamin Ian Perry, Swaran Preet Singh, David Hedley White); (4) Deprivation of Liberty: the position in Scotland (Laura Jean Dunlop). See International Journal of Mental Health and Capacity Law
- Law Society, 'In conversation with... Craig Ward' (podcast, 10/7/17). This podcast is about business LPAs. See Lasting Power of Attorney#Law Society
Events
- Court of Protection User Group - London, 11/10/17 — No results See Events
- Healthcare Conferences UK: DOLS: Towards Liberty Protection Safeguards - London, 8/12/17 — No results See Events
- Edge Training: DOLS: a new beginning? - London, 9/10/17 — No results See Events
- Edge Training: Deprivation of liberty in the community - London, 6/10/17 — No results See Events
- Difficult Conversations: End of Life Care: Advanced Legal Issues Masterclass - London, 29/11/17 — No results See Events
- Difficult Conversations: End of Life Care: Advanced Legal Issues Masterclass - London, 12/10/17 — No results See Events
- CDLP: Making our own Decisions: Sharing Stories and Creating Change - Galway, 22/11/17 — No results See Events
Jobs
The following jobs were advertised in August 2017 (and the deadline has now passed).
- Job advert. ODonnells Solicitors, Preston - Court of Protection solicitor (deadline 29/9/17). See Jobs
DoLs and LPA applications continue to increase sharply - The numbers of applications for DoLs and LPAs have con... https://t.co/T7WQmKDXPM
— CoP Made Clear (@CoPhub) September 28, 2017
https://t.co/ANNmzaYFSY An analysis of the case of Re X (The blood on their hands case)
— Peter Edwards (@peteredwardslaw) September 28, 2017
Read the full report if you want to know more about the CoP's welfare jurisdiction! https://t.co/kC01NLFnIi
— Lucy Series (@TheSmallPlaces) September 28, 2017
'Mentally impaired' missing out on council tax discount https://t.co/Hk4pe4213k
— BBC Health News (@bbchealth) September 29, 2017
Francis J reported as saying during a Court of Protection hearing that advance decisions should be compulsory. https://t.co/DjGbYnn7N4
— Jean McHale (@JeanMcHale2) September 27, 2017
The accessibility of a personal welfare route ...to challenge best interests decisions ...borders on the fictitioushttps://t.co/jE8cV5KEQm
— CSEP Manchester (@BioethicsUoM) September 29, 2017
LAA Update: National Statistics: Legal aid statistics: October to December 2016 https://t.co/3v9uwwvZoU
— Legal Aid Handbook (@legalaidhbk) March 30, 2017
We know more people are being detained under the MHA 1983, yet there is a significant decrease in publicly funded mental health cases - why? https://t.co/yRZmBfD9HI
— Sheree Green (@ShereeGreen17) September 28, 2017
If interested, part of the symposium in Iceland containing my talk on policing and mental health (from 1hr 8mins) - https://t.co/J5mJbMtGxM
— Insp Michael Brown (@MentalHealthCop) September 29, 2017
Law Society, 'In conversation with... Craig Ward' (podcast, 10/7/17).: This podcast is about business LPAs. See… https://t.co/Ve2FZur4eV
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 29, 2017
Aasya Mughal and Steven Richards, 'Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards Case Law Summary 2015-17' (September 2017… https://t.co/oyI5QEVhAa
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 29, 2017
Excellent blog: When does a detained mental health patient leave hospital so aftercare duty under s117 MHA arises: https://t.co/c2LXoXHFWO
— David Lock QC (@DavidLockQC) September 25, 2017
"Power of attorney could be granted online under FCA proposals" | via @telegraph https://t.co/HKWFUsOvvV
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 25, 2017
Latest rumour I'm hearing on an implementation date for ss135/6 MHA amendments is - late November / early December. I hope they mean 2017! ????
— Insp Michael Brown (@MentalHealthCop) September 25, 2017
Court of Protection: SCC v MSA & Anor [2017] EWCOP 18 (20 September 2017) https://t.co/hni4d9S5tt
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 23, 2017
IJMHCL third edition.: [2017] IJMHCL pages 1-83. The articles in this edition are: (1) Editorial (Darius Whelan,… https://t.co/rhp6mYZwao
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 21, 2017
IJMHCL second edition.: [2016] IJMHCL pages 71-143. In the archives, the first and second editions are both called… https://t.co/tTLM7SAgkk
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 21, 2017
"Mental health trust pays damages over man's death in tower block fire" https://t.co/5S00gRcbCY
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 21, 2017
Useful healthcare guidance for COP lawyers involved in cases about incapacitated adults taken abroad/wanting to go abroad https://t.co/kz37a37GwM
— Tor Butler-Cole (@TorButlerCole) September 21, 2017
Find out more about the new, updated version of our "Flying Home" guidance: https://t.co/nig3502b84 #eolc #support #advice @hospicedoctor pic.twitter.com/EGberLusfp
— Hospice UK (@hospiceuk) September 20, 2017
Civil contracts for 2018 – tender open https://t.co/Zx2tS5zjar
— Legal Aid Handbook (@legalaidhbk) September 21, 2017
We've now launched an investigation focusing on the provision of mental health services in emergency departments https://t.co/C76TZPzUxa
— HSIB (@hSafetyIB) September 19, 2017
Court of Protection judgment M -v- A Hospital. Withdrawal of Treatment: Need for Proceedings https://t.co/nuaWXvKldq pic.twitter.com/hyQU2xHdMY
— Judicial Office (@JudiciaryUK) September 21, 2017
After-care case. R (CXF) v Central Bedfordshire Council [2017] EWHC 2311 (Admin), [2017] MHLO 30: — "The central… https://t.co/haTNYq4Lct
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 20, 2017
Deportation case. SSHD v KE (Nigeria) [2017] EWCA Civ 1382, [2017] MHLO 29: — "This is an appeal [which] gives rise… https://t.co/VlEbJI4S83
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 20, 2017
Kings Chambers: Religious Observance and the Incapacitated Adult - Leeds, 20/9/17: — This seminar will consider the… https://t.co/BGGkENgS9r
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 20, 2017
Court of Protection User Group - London, 11/10/17: — This meeting is open to the public, but is more relevant to… https://t.co/HPMeMmUMnm
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 20, 2017
Healthcare Conferences UK: DOLS: Towards Liberty Protection Safeguards - London, 8/12/17: — This conference will… https://t.co/f9ifJ38vJh
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 20, 2017
Edge Training: DOLS: a new beginning? - London, 9/10/17: — This half-day course aims to provide a detailed overview… https://t.co/EQvj5dcTvA
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 20, 2017
Court of Protection: M v A Hospital [2017] EWCOP 19 (20 September 2017) https://t.co/JKMWm0BUQ1
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 20, 2017
Southern Health NHS Trust admits guilt over Connor Sparrowhawk's death https://t.co/7NzsLkMi3m
— BBC Health News (@bbchealth) September 18, 2017
New (free) online resources on social care law in Wales! https://t.co/5TqRpBb7ML Please circulate to all and anyone who needs it
— Lucy Series (@TheSmallPlaces) September 14, 2017
Court of Protection: D, Re (Medical Treatment) [2017] EWCOP 15 (05 September 2017) https://t.co/yERTbe79Sd
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 15, 2017
The September Mental Capacity Reports are now available https://t.co/XVITJZZlEQ
— Mental Capacity Law (@39CapacityLaw) September 12, 2017
Edge Training: Deprivation of liberty in the community - London, 6/10/17: — This one-day course is designed to… https://t.co/uzMTGKL7Bs
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 12, 2017
Job advert. ODonnells Solicitors, Preston - Court of Protection solicitor (deadline 29/9/17).: See Jobs https://t.co/SeLVfikd1K
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 8, 2017
Job advert. ODonnells Solicitors, Preston - Mental health panel member (deadline 29/9/17).: See Jobs https://t.co/6FnHDmDbHh
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 8, 2017
Difficult Conversations: End of Life Care: Advanced Legal Issues Masterclass - London, 29/11/17: — This half-day… https://t.co/VtvqgI9Hoa
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 8, 2017
Difficult Conversations: End of Life Care: Advanced Legal Issues Masterclass - London, 12/10/17: — This half-day… https://t.co/vD2ConJCzz
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 8, 2017
Upper Tribunal case. JMcG v Devon Partnership NHS Trust [2017] UKUT 348 (AAC), [2017] MHLO 28: — "The principal… https://t.co/kD3T5g2CAN
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 8, 2017
Difficult Conversations: End of Life Care: Advanced Legal Issues Masterclass - London, 29/11/17: — This half-day… https://t.co/8h6a5KkgeV
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 8, 2017
Difficult Conversations: End of Life Care: Advanced Legal Issues Masterclass - London, 12/10/17: — This half-day… https://t.co/rNAEmivwIu
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 8, 2017
Upper Tribunal case. JMcG v Devon Partnership NHS Trust [2017] UKUT 348 (AAC), [2017] MHLO 28: — "The principal… https://t.co/w9gR4CfKQ0
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 8, 2017
Judge agrees artificial nutrition for mentally ill man who swallows sharp items https://t.co/2YcRAWP2O8 via @careapps
— Celia Kitzinger (@KitzingerCelia) September 4, 2017
"Families of people who died in police custody failed by system – report" https://t.co/nFA7ohEyy1
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 5, 2017
"Police chief 'built story' about man with mental health issues hearing told" https://t.co/c24GU7Uhqu
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 5, 2017
Court of Protection: The Public Guardian v Matrix Deputies Ltd & Anor [2017] EWCOP 14 (19 July 2017) https://t.co/eGeOwg0yMv
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 2, 2017
"Woman awarded £11,000 in disability discrimination case" BBC News https://t.co/ZU4lhyJikh
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 1, 2017
One in three sick notes are for mental health problems, 'alarming' report shows ' | via @telegraph https://t.co/VBA8USQLB1
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 1, 2017
UN Disability Rights Committee issues 'concluding observations' on the UK: https://t.co/eV4jMib3P0
— Oliver Lewis (@olewis75) August 31, 2017
UN panel criticises UK failure to uphold disabled people's rights https://t.co/6jqBOXBOt3
— Mental Health Law (@MHLonline) September 1, 2017
CRPD Committee tells UK to "abolish all forms of substituted decision-making, and to change "both mental capacity and mental health laws"
— Oliver Lewis (@olewis75) August 31, 2017