Southern Health NHS Foundation Trust v AB [2019] EWCOP 11

Injunction against publication of video "This is an application to prevent publication of a video of a patient, AB, in her treating hospital. ... At times she is catatonic and lies in a foetal position on the floor. She has a history during these periods of self-harm, and for that reason she wears protective headgear at all times. In the light of AB's condition and the difficulties in accommodating her appropriately, the Trust has had to adapt the room in which she has been living urgently, and it is true to say that the condition of the room therefore looks somewhat poor. ... On about 20 January 2019, AB's son, W, who is the second respondent, took a video recording of his mother in her room. ... I am clear that it is appropriate in these circumstances to make the order. First of all, having seen the video, it is apparent that AB can be identified, even if pixilated, and would be identifiable from the information that Mail Online intend to publish. ... Secondly, it is clear from Dr Marlowe's statements that AB does not currently have capacity ... Thirdly, I have no doubt, having watched it, that the video would be an interference with AB's privacy and her private life. ... The draft order provides for W being able to apply to the court at a full hearing if he wishes to do so to seek to lift the injunction, and argue that it is in her interests to publish the video. Further, according to Dr Marlowe, AB may well regain capacity herself relatively shortly, i.e. within a matter of weeks, and if she then wishes for publication, that will be a matter for her."

Note

This case originally appeared on Bailii with the neutral citation number [2019] EWCOP 10^M, but that NCN was subsequently taken by another case, and this case changed to (2019) EWCOP 11^B.

Essex search

This case's neutral citation number appears in the following newsletters:

• 39 Essex Chambers, 'Mental Capacity Report' (issue 93, April 2019)

CASES DATABASE

Full judgment: BAILII

Subject(s):

• Reporting restriction order cases🔍 Older RRO cases can still be found in Category:Other capacity cases

Date: 29/1/19🔍

Court: Court of Protection🔍

Judge(s):

• Lieven🔍

Parties:

• Southern Health NHS Foundation Trust🔍
• AB🔍

Citation number(s):

• [2019] EWCOP 11^B

What links here:

• East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust v PW [2019] EWCOP 10

Published: 23/3/19 17:33

Cached: 2024-04-20 11:18:12